Skip to content
Newsletter

Before you make it · No. 19

Roast potatoes: choose your crispness plan

Fridge overnight, peel the day before, or roast the whole tray tomorrow? We read four named recipes so you can see what each plan asks of the oven before you shop.

Golden roast potatoes on a dark tray, one broken open to a fluffy center, with rosemary and salt.

Say you might roast potatoes for guests tomorrow. You can do some of the work today. You want them crisp when people eat, and you want to know what each cook prints for the parboil, the fat, the oven, and the tray.

We read four named recipes and pulled out those levers, plus what each page says you can do ahead. We haven't cooked these versions. Everything practical below comes from the named page and is linked, so you can check it. Cook from the recipe you choose.

At a glance

How each recipe fits this plan

GUESTS TOMORROWWHAT YOU CAN DO TODAYOVEN SLOT TOMORROW
  1. No image yet

    Jamie Oliver

    Parboil, dry, and coat, then cover and refrigerate overnight. Roast tomorrow at 180°C/350°F/gas 4 for 1 hour, squash, then 20 to 25 minutes more. The same coated potatoes can go in the freezer.

    Fits your plan Prep tonight Recipe by Jamie Oliver
  2. No image yet

    Nigella Lawson

    Peel the day before and keep the potatoes whole in cold water in a cold place. Tomorrow they are boiled 4 minutes, rolled in semolina, and roasted in goose fat she heats in the oven for 20 to 30 minutes.

    Plan around this Peel-ahead only500°F printed Recipe by Nigella Lawson
  3. No image yet

    Ina Garten

    No parboil on the print page. Olive oil, one layer on a baking sheet, 400 degrees, at least 1 hour, flipped twice. The print page does not name the degree unit, and it does not print an ahead or reheat line.

    Fits your plan Unit not printedNo ahead line Recipe by Ina Garten, Barefoot Contessa
  4. No image yet

    Mary Berry

    Parboil about 5 minutes, roughen, coat with semolina, and roast 45 to 55 minutes. She says they can be roasted up to 12 hours ahead, then reheated 15 to 20 minutes in a hot oven. The preheat line prints 425°F twice.

    Plan around this 12-hour window425°F printed twice Recipe by Mary Berry, via The Happy Foodie
Flags are our reading of each published plan against guests tomorrow. They are not a ranking of crispness.

Jamie Oliver

Fits your planPrep tonight

From Best roast potatoes by Jamie Oliver. The page credits Jamie Oliver's Christmas Cookbook, p108, and also says the recipe is from Jamie's Cook-Ahead Christmas. No date on the page.

Card
2 hrs, serves 10
Parboil
15 min
Oven
180°C/350°F/gas 4
After squash
20–25 min

The card prints 2 hrs, Super easy, and serves 10. The potatoes are medium and floury. He names Maris Piper or King Edward. They stay whole, ideally about the same size, and he gives 8cm. Parboil them in boiling salted water for 15 minutes, steam-dry for 2 minutes, then shake the colander so the edges roughen.

The fat is goose fat or unsalted butter, plus olive oil. Toss, then “spread out in one fairly snug, even layer but with small gaps between them.” “Cover and pop in the fridge overnight.” The next sentence is the freezer route for that same stage: “Or, you can make these up to 1 month in advance – simply leave to cool, then cover and pop in the freezer.” The page does not print a reheat for potatoes that have already been roasted.

On the day the oven is 180°C/350°F/gas 4. The page does not print a fan setting. Roast 1 hour, “or until the potatoes are crisp and golden all over” (“if cooking straight from frozen, roast for 1 hour 15 minutes”). Then half-squash each potato “so they kind of push into each other and fill the tray.” Roast 20 to 25 minutes more. The same URL prints a separate air-fryer method, with the drawer preheated to 180ºC, 30 minutes, then 15 minutes after squashing. Those times stay with the air fryer.

For this plan

Our reading: tomorrow fits the overnight fridge line if the potatoes are parboiled and coated today. The roast is still a long oven slot tomorrow. Adding the printed hour to the printed 20 to 25 minutes gives 80 to 85 minutes after the oven is hot. That sum is ours. It leaves out preheat, the 15-minute parboil, and the squash. The card's 2 hrs is a separate printed total, and the overnight hold sits outside both. From frozen, the first roast on the page is 1 hour 15 minutes, then the same squash and the same 20 to 25 minutes.

The page names two books, as the source line says. We read the web page, not either book.

Nigella Lawson

Plan around thisPeel-ahead only500°F printed

From Perfect Roast Potatoes by Nigella Lawson. Featured in Nigella Christmas.

Serves
10–16 with the meal
Parboil
4 min once boiling
Fat in oven
20–30 min
Oven
250°C/230°C fan/gas 9

She names King Edward's or Yukon Gold, and she cuts each potato into three. In the introduction, crispness is three things she wants together: fat that is searingly hot, potatoes small enough that the outside keeps up with the inside, and semolina rather than flour after the parboil, plus a bash so the surface catches. “if it’s not searingly hot, you don’t stand a chance”. Goose fat is what she names, for a high smoking point. The page does not print a second fat.

The method starts the potatoes in cold salted water, brings them to a boil, and lets them cook for 4 minutes. Semolina goes on after draining. She shakes them, then bashes the pan “so that their edges fuzz and blur a little”. “I leave them to rest at this stage.” She does not time that rest. If you skip it, she says you need the oven on earlier. The oven line is 250°C/230°C Fan/gas mark 9/500°F. A single oven, on her page, waits: “If you don’t have a double oven, you will have to do this as soon as the turkey is out of your single oven, which, for me, is very much later than the parboiling stage.” The fat goes into a large roasting tin for 20–30 minutes until it is frighteningly hot. Then the potatoes roast for an hour, turned halfway, until darkly golden and crispy. She also writes that a hot enough oven “may well not need more than about 25 minutes a side”. The hour and the side-count are both printed.

The make-ahead line is peel only. “Peel the potatoes the day before. Keep submerged, whole, in cold water in a cold place.” Drain, cut, and use fresh salted water when you parboil. The method we read does not then tell you to reheat roasted potatoes. It also does not say how far apart they sit in the tin. Comments under the recipe, including notes about crowding and about other fats, are not her instruction.

For this plan

Our reading: tomorrow still includes the boil, the 20 to 30 minutes of fat in the oven, and the roast. The day-before line is the peel-and-water hold, in her words a cold place. This page is the highest oven setting printed in the four plans. Her single-oven sentence is about a turkey coming out first. Count that only if your oven is shared the way she describes. We are not choosing between her hour and her 25 minutes a side.

The page says the recipe is featured in Nigella Christmas. A year is not printed on this recipe page. We read the page, not the book.

Ina Garten

Fits your planUnit not printedNo ahead line

From Garlic Roasted Potatoes by Ina Garten, Barefoot Contessa. Print view; Barefoot Contessa Parties!.

Parboil
None on this page
Oven
400 degrees
Roast
At least 1 hour
Layer
One, on a sheet

The print page calls for small red- or white-skinned potatoes, or a mixture. It does not name a variety. Cut them into halves or quarters, toss with olive oil, salt, pepper, and minced garlic, and “spread out into one layer”. There is no parboil in the method. That is an observation of this print view: cutting and coating lead straight to the oven.

“Preheat the oven to 400 degrees.” The unit is not on this page. Roast “for at least 1 hour, or until browned and crisp.” “Flip twice with a spatula during cooking to ensure even browning.” The print view has no make-ahead line and no reheating line. Food Network prints the same recipe title, from the same book, as 400 degrees F and 45 minutes to 1 hour, with a card total of 1 hr 10 min, prep 10 min, cook 1 hr, and 8 servings. Its ingredient line says small red or white potatoes. Checked October 28, 2026. The two durations stay on their own pages.

For this plan

Our reading: tomorrow can be the whole method if the oven is free for at least the hour she prints, plus the two flips. Nothing on the print page moves the roast to today. Cook the Barefoot print page at “at least 1 hour, or until browned and crisp.” The Food Network range is a different printing.

This is the Barefoot Contessa print view. The page names the book Barefoot Contessa Parties! We did not find a year on this print view.

Mary Berry

Plan around this12-hour window425°F printed twice

From Mary Berry's Best Roast Potatoes by Mary Berry, via The Happy Foodie. From Simple Comforts.

Parboil
About 5 min
Oven line
425°F printed twice
Roast
45–55 min
Ahead
Up to 12 hours

The Happy Foodie page, from Simple Comforts, says serves 6 and Easy. The potatoes are Maris Piper or King Edward, in medium chunks. Cold salted water, then a boil of about 5 minutes “until the potatoes are starting to soften around the edges.” Drain until completely dry, shake to rough the edges, add semolina, and shake until coated. She names goose fat plus sunflower oil. “If you don’t have any goose fat, use extra sunflower oil.” Heat a roasting tin, add the fat and oil, and heat 5 minutes until smoking.

The oven line is printed as “220°C (425°F)/200°C (425°F) fan/Gas 7.” Both Fahrenheit figures are 425°F. Roast about 45–55 minutes, turning halfway, until golden brown and crisp, and serve piping hot. The method names a roasting tin and does not say how to space the potatoes or whether they must sit in one layer.

Her note says: “Can be roasted up to 12 hours ahead. Before serving, reheat in a hot oven for 15–20 minutes – no need to add extra fat.” The note’s words are “a hot oven”, and they are not given a number. The note does not say fridge, counter, or a covered tray. Replies under the reviews are not that note.

For this plan

Our reading: a tray roasted tonight does not automatically feed a meal tomorrow evening. Twelve hours is the window she printed. The reheat is 15 to 20 minutes, and the oven number for that reheat is not on the note. Leave the duplicated 425°F as printed. The Christmas Collection recipe on her own site is a different page, with its own overnight line, and it does not lengthen these 12 hours.

We read this Simple Comforts excerpt, not the book. Reader reviews, and the publisher replies under them, are not her method.

The short version

For guests tomorrow, the split is what each page lets you finish today.

Jamie Oliver prints the overnight stop that happens before roasting. Parboil, dry, coat, then cover and refrigerate overnight, and roast the next day. His card says 2 hrs, serves 10. The method still prints about an hour in the oven, a squash, then 20 to 25 minutes more. The same coated potatoes can go in the freezer for up to 1 month. The page does not print a reheat for potatoes that have already been roasted. The oven line does not print a fan setting.

Nigella Lawson’s ahead line is peel the day before and keep the potatoes whole, submerged, in cold water in a cold place. The boil, the fat, and the roast stay on the day. She prints 250°C/230°C Fan/gas mark 9/500°F, and she heats the goose fat in the oven for 20 to 30 minutes before the potatoes go in. She also prints both an hour and about 25 minutes a side.

Ina Garten’s print page has no parboil and no ahead line. Halves or quarters, olive oil, one layer, at least 1 hour at 400 degrees. The page does not name the degree unit. The potatoes are small and red- or white-skinned. A variety name is not on that page.

Mary Berry’s Simple Comforts page, on The Happy Foodie, is the one that says the potatoes can be roasted ahead: up to 12 hours, then 15 to 20 minutes in a hot oven, with no extra fat. Twelve hours is the window on the note. Her preheat line prints 425°F next to 220°C and again next to 200°C fan. Leave that line as printed.

None of the four says how long the crust stays crisp on the table, under a cover, or next to gravy. We have not cooked these versions, and the flags are not a crispness ranking. Keep each cook’s plan whole. A shorter time, a preferred fat, and a hotter oven from three different pages are not a fifth recipe.

Where the four plans disagree

The parboil is the first split. Jamie uses 15 minutes in boiling salted water, then 2 minutes of steam-drying, whole potatoes about 8cm, and he names Maris Piper or King Edward as floury potatoes. Nigella starts in cold water, cooks 4 minutes once boiling, then semolina, and she cuts each potato into three. She names King Edward’s or Yukon Gold. Mary, on the Simple Comforts page, starts in cold water, boils about 5 minutes until the edges soften, then semolina. She names Maris Piper or King Edward, in medium chunks. Ina’s print page has no parboil. She calls for small red- or white-skinned potatoes and does not name a variety. The names stay on the page that prints them. Nigella’s slash is her wording for the potatoes she lists. It is not a finding that those potatoes cook the same, and it is not a license to swap in a potato none of them named.

The fat is the second split. Jamie tosses goose fat or unsalted butter, plus olive oil, before the fridge. Nigella heats goose fat in the tin for 20–30 minutes and wants it searingly hot. Mary heats goose fat plus sunflower oil for 5 minutes, until smoking, and she prints extra sunflower oil as the stand-in when there is no goose fat. Ina tosses olive oil with the cut potatoes and does not print a separate fat-heating step. Use the fat with the clock from the same page.

The oven is the third split. Jamie prints 180°C/350°F/gas 4, a first roast of 1 hour (1 hour 15 minutes from frozen), then 20 to 25 minutes after squashing. Nigella prints 250°C/230°C Fan/gas mark 9/500°F, about 1 hour with a turn halfway, and about 25 minutes a side if the oven is hot enough. Mary prints the doubled 425°F line above, then 45–55 minutes, turned halfway. Ina prints 400 degrees and at least 1 hour, flipped twice. Food Network’s page of this Ina recipe prints 400 degrees F and 45 minutes to 1 hour. Cook the duration on the page you are using. The same Jamie URL also prints an air-fryer clock, 30 minutes plus 15, at 180ºC. That clock is the drawer, not the oven plan.

The tray is the fourth split. Jamie starts with one fairly snug, even layer and small gaps, then squashes the potatoes until they fill the tray. Ina says one layer on a baking sheet. Nigella specifies a large roasting tin and does not say how to space the potatoes. Mary specifies a roasting tin and does not say. Where a page is silent, the gap stays open. It does not become permission to pile the tray, and Jamie’s snug layer does not become a rule for the other three. Comments on Nigella’s page about crowding are not her method.

The ahead line is the one that decides tonight. Jamie’s fridge sentence, and his freezer sentence, apply after parboiling and coating. Nigella’s day-before sentence is whole peeled potatoes in cold water in a cold place. Ina’s print page has neither. Mary’s Simple Comforts note is a finished roast, up to 12 hours ahead, then 15–20 minutes in a hot oven. Her own Christmas Collection page is a different recipe. The introduction there says the potatoes need about 20 minutes in a hot oven on the day. The preparing-ahead note says a 20-30 minute par-roast, a cool place overnight, then about 30 minutes at the same hot temperature, which that page prints as 220C/fan 200C/gas 7. Those two finish times do not match each other. The ingredients line there names “desirée, king edward or maris piper”, in that lowercase. That overnight route stays on that page. It does not extend the Simple Comforts window of 12 hours.

Cooling and reheating, from the official pages

The recipes use their own storage words. Jamie says the fridge. Nigella says a cold place. The Christmas Collection page says a cool place. The Simple Comforts note does not say where the roasted potatoes sit during the 12 hours. Those phrases stay attached to the cook who printed them. This page does not translate “cold place” or “cool place” into a Sensory Cooking storage rule, and it does not fill Mary’s gap from the review replies under the Happy Foodie recipe.

The official pages linked here are the Food Standards Agency’s How to chill, freeze and defrost food safely and Cooking your food. Both say they apply to England, Northern Ireland and Wales, and both were published 18 December 2017. Checked October 28, 2026.

The chilling page says: “Don’t place hot or warm food in your fridge. Instead, cool cooked food at room temperature and place in the fridge within one to two hours.” It also says “your fridge should be between 0 and 5°C and your freezer should be around -18°C”. That is the signpost when a recipe already says fridge, as Jamie’s does. His instruction still says overnight. The agency line does not replace it, and it does not turn Nigella’s “cold place” into a fridge.

The cooking page says to “always follow cooking temperature guidelines according to the recipe or packet instructions carefully” and that reheated food should be “steaming hot throughout, rather than warmed”. It says “When reheating leftovers, you should only ever reheat once.” Mary’s 15 to 20 minutes in a hot oven remains her line. The agency page does not number that oven. This guide does not invent the number, and it does not borrow a temperature from another cook to stand in for it.

“Cover and pop in the fridge overnight.”

Jamie Oliver

“If you don’t have a double oven, you will have to do this as soon as the turkey is out of your single oven, which, for me, is very much later than the parboiling stage.”

Nigella Lawson

“Can be roasted up to 12 hours ahead.”

Mary Berry, via The Happy Foodie