Skip to content
Newsletter

Before you make it · No. 13

Cheese naan for tonight

Stuffed dough, or cheese on a packet naan? A skillet, an oven, or the grill? We read four named pages so you can see what the dough, the pan, and the melted cheese ask of you before you shop.

Say you want cheese naan for people eating tonight. You cook occasionally. You have a skillet, and an oven is a maybe. You want to know whether the cheese has to be sealed inside the dough, and whether the bread can sit while the rest of the batch cooks.

We read four named pages and pulled out the clock, the pan, and what each cook says about serving. One page is a chilli cheese naan. One is cheese on a shop-bought naan, not a stuffed dough. We haven't cooked these versions. Everything practical below comes from the named page and is linked, so you can check it. Cook from the page you choose.

At a glance

How each recipe fits this plan

EAT TONIGHTDOUGH OR A PACKETSERVE AS THEY COME OFF
  1. No image yet

    Sanjana Modha

    Card total 1 hour 20 minutes, for 6 naans. Yeast-free dough, cheese stuffed inside. Frying pan, oven, or under the grill, and those grill times do not match. Serve immediately, or into an insulated container with no minute count.

    Plan around this Grill clocks disagree Recipe by Sanjana Modha, Sanjana Feasts
  2. No image yet

    Jennifer Pallian

    Card total 1 hour 32 minutes, with 2 minutes of cooking listed for 8 naans. Covered cast iron, and her FAQ allows non-stick. A towel keeps cooked naan warm. She does not time the cheese pull.

    Plan around this 2-minute cook line Recipe by Jennifer Pallian, Foodess
  3. No image yet

    Nagi Maehashi

    The card lists 20 minutes prep, 10 minutes cook, and 2 hours rising, for 6 naans. No kneading, and still a long rise. Cast iron, not non-stick. Cheese goes in before the skillet. Serve hot, with no measured hold.

    Plan around this Six naans vs 10 minutes Recipe by Nagi Maehashi, RecipeTin Eats
  4. No image yet

    Nigella Lawson

    Shop-bought naan, cheese on top, about 5 minutes in a preheated oven. Serves 1. She says not to make it ahead or store it. No stuffed dough, no skillet, no grill.

    Fits your plan Topped, not stuffed Recipe by Nigella Lawson
Flags are our reading of each page against eating tonight. They are not a taste ranking and not a kitchen test.

Sanjana Modha

Plan around thisGrill clocks disagree

From Chilli Cheese Naan by Sanjana Modha, Sanjana Feasts. Published July 22, 2021; updated December 6, 2024.

Prep
1 hour
Cook
20 min
Card total
1 hr 20 min
Yield
6 naans

The card lists 1 hour prep, 20 minutes cook, and a total of 1 hour 20 minutes, for 6 naans. The troubleshooting, not the card, says to rest the dough, covered, for at least 30 minutes after kneading. One hour plus 20 minutes is the total she prints, so that rest may already sit inside the prep hour. The card does not say so.

She writes, “It’s a yeast-free naan recipe which uses self-raising flour and additional baking powder for the softest cheese naan you will ever eat.” That last claim is hers. We have not eaten it. The dough list has no egg. The stuffing she names is low-moisture mozzarella and Cheddar, with chillies. She ties that combination to what she calls stretchy cheese pulls.

Her main method is an upside-down pan. She writes that most of us do not have tandoors, and she offers that pan as the way to a tandoori-style finish without one. “You can also use a frying pan, but this method will not work on non-stick surfaces.” The both-sides fry says the opposite about the pan: “Non-stick is fine to use in this case.” Use the pan rule that belongs to the method you cook. That frying-pan paragraph also says you can finish under the grill or over an open flame. We are reading the open flame as a hob, the way the upside-down pan uses one. She does not describe an outdoor barbecue.

The oven line, in the essay and again in the notes, is a lined tray at 220°C/430°F for 4 to 5 minutes. The grill clocks do not match. The essay says cook under the grill on both sides for a minute or two, and “Keep an eye on them at all times to make sure they don’t burn.” The notes say place the naans under the grill for a few seconds. She writes “under the grill.” On a British cooker that is the broiler. She does not give a rack position.

On the dough, she writes that it can be too dry or hard, and to add more water. Unrested dough is on the same list. “Any cracks will ooze cheese during the cooking process.” A little ooze is fine, she writes, and she does not want it all to leak out. The dough will keep in the refrigerator for two days, wrapped or in an airtight container. She also says it is best within 48 hours, because the baking powder loses its leavening and the naan is less puffy. Both clocks are on the page.

“Serve immediately or keep the naan in an insulated container while you cook the rest of them.” She does not say how long that container holds a cheese pull. We did not find a time for cooked leftovers on the page.

For this plan

Our reading: tonight can fit the 1 hour 20 minute card if you start early enough for a first attempt. It does not fit a plan that needs bread in under an hour from a standing start. If the breads have to be ready well before anyone eats, she does not time the insulated container. Follow one of her methods whole. The grill minute-or-two and the grill few-seconds are not the same instruction.

The visible line says published July 22, 2021, last updated December 6, 2024. The recipe schema on the same page has a separate datePublished of August 18, 2023. We used the visible post dates. The byline on the page is Sanjana. Sanjana Modha is the name in the site navigation.

Jennifer Pallian

Plan around this2-minute cook line

From Cheese Naan by Jennifer Pallian, Foodess. Updated March 10, 2025.

Prep
15 min
Cook
2 min
Rest
1 hr 15 min
Card total
1 hr 32 min

The visible byline says updated March 10, 2025. The recipe schema also carries a published time of July 18, 2024, which that byline does not print. The card lists 15 minutes prep, 2 minutes cook, 1 hour 15 minutes resting, and a total of 1 hour 32 minutes, for 8 servings. Those three lines add to the total she prints. The card does not show the about 5 minutes she uses to heat the skillet.

The dough is yeast and yogurt. The printed list has no egg. The filling she describes is shredded mozzarella. She cooks in a covered cast-iron skillet. The FAQ allows a regular non-stick skillet or griddle, preheated well. That permission is the opposite of the non-stick warnings on the other stuffed pages. It belongs to her dough and her heat.

One naan, in the method, is covered for 30 to 60 seconds, then about 30 seconds more after the flip. The card's cook time is 2 minutes, for 8 servings. Eight pieces at the short end of those times is 8 minutes, and the long end is 12, before the pan heats. We cannot tell whether the 2 minutes means one naan or the batch. The page does not say.

What she says goes wrong: extra flour leads to a dense, dry dough. Skipping the rise costs the lightness she wants, a full hour or until the dough has doubled. “Adding too much cheese causes it to leak out during cooking.” If it does not puff, she points at a pan that is not hot enough, or dough that is not rolled evenly. By hand, the FAQ says about 8 to 10 minutes of kneading, and a later note says about 10 minutes. The mistakes section says to avoid extra flour. The hand-knead answers mention a floured surface. We are not choosing which sentence governs.

She also prints a gas-burner variation she calls tandoori-style. It is timed in seconds, and “Be attentive as the naan can burn quickly.” That is a lit gas burner. It is not an outdoor grill, and it is not a clay tandoor. Her oven directions are for reheating cooked naan, not for cooking the raw dough. A note on the same page says dough water of 120°F to 130°F, because water that is too hot can kill the yeast and cooler water slows the rise. That is her yeast line. It is not a temperature for the finished bread.

Make-ahead, as she prints it, is the risen dough. Up to 24 hours in the refrigerator, then back to room temperature before rolling. Or frozen up to 3 months, thawed overnight in the refrigerator, then brought to room temperature. Cooked naan goes onto a plate and is covered with a towel to keep warm. She does not time that towel. She does print storage times for cooked leftovers. This page does not repeat them.

For this plan

Our reading: treat 1 hour 32 minutes as a planning lead, not as a promise that eight cheese naans leave the skillet in 2 minutes. Tonight fits if the dough gets its rest and you serve as they come off the pan. A batch that has to wait, with the cheese still pulling, is the part she does not time.

The hand-knead clocks and the flour warnings are both on her page. We did not resolve them. Cooked-leftover times from this page are in the claim ledger and are not repeated here.

Nagi Maehashi

Plan around thisSix naans vs 10 minutes

From Naan recipe – chewy & fluffy! by Nagi Maehashi, RecipeTin Eats. Published February 24, 2021; updated April 28, 2025.

Prep
20 min
Cook
10 min
Rising
2 hours
Yield
6 naans

The card lists 20 minutes prep, 10 minutes cook, and 2 hours of dough rising, for 6 naans. She does not print one total. Those three lines add to 2 hours 30 minutes. That addition is ours. The dough includes yeast, egg, and milk. The instructions say “No kneading is required.” On the egg she writes, “Any more and it dries out the inside too much.” No kneading is not the same thing as no waiting. The rise is still on the card.

The cheese goes in before the skillet. She contrasts that with restaurants: “In restaurants, cheese naan is usually made by cooking plain naan first, then cutting a slit and stuffing inside the naan with cheese to melt.” She calls the slit tedious. We are not copying either way of shaping it. “Monterey Jack is a good option that has flavour and stretches nicely!” Mozzarella, she writes, “doesn’t have much flavour.” Any melting cheese works, in that note. We have not compared them.

The cheese skillet is cast iron over high heat, “but not until the skillet is smoking,” about 1 1/2 minutes on the first side and about 45 seconds on the second. That is about 2 minutes 15 seconds for one naan. Her plain-naan essay, earlier on the page, says 2 to 2 1/2 minutes total is ideal, and that beyond this the naan starts to dry out inside. The same essay heats the skillet until it is just starting to smoke. The cheese section is the heat line that belongs to the cheese naan. Note 8 says, “DO NOT use a non-stick pan – the high heat required to properly cook naan will destroy the non-stick coating!” She gives no oven, broiler, or outdoor-grill method for the raw dough. She writes, “No fiercely hot tandoor required.”

Six cheese naans at those side times is 13 minutes 30 seconds of cooking, before the pan heats. The card's cook line is 10 minutes. Our reading of the arithmetic: the per-naan cheese times, times six, run past that 10-minute line. We have not cooked a batch.

Make-ahead is the dough after the first rise, into the fridge overnight. “I’ve done 24 hours.” Take it out at least a couple of hours before cooking, “otherwise the dough won’t rise for Proof #2.” Cold dough moves the work. It does not remove the wait on the day you cook. The finishing step says “Serve hot!” That sentence sits just before the cheese heading. The cheese variant does not add a minute count for the stretch, and we did not find a storage limit for cooked cheese naan.

For this plan

Our reading: tonight has to hold the 2 hours of rising, the couple of hours out of the fridge if the dough was chilled, and a batch that may run past the 10-minute cook line. The tandoor sentence means she is not asking you to own one. It is not a method for cooking in one.

The plain-naan essay and the cheese section print different skillet-heat lines. Cook the cheese naan from the cheese section. The cookbook mention on the page is her book Dinner. We read the web page, not the book.

Nigella Lawson

Fits your planTopped, not stuffed

From Naan Pizza by Nigella Lawson. No web date; featured in Nigella Express (2007).

In the oven
About 5 min
Oven
425ºF / gas 7
Serves
1
Ahead
Not advised

This is the packet path, and it is a different dish. One shop-bought naan, tomato and mushrooms, fontina or Gruyère on top. She writes, “while shop-bought pizzas are vile, packet naans, when heated, are not.” The page has no stuffed dough, no skillet, and no grill. It serves 1.

Heat the oven to 220°C/200°C Fan/gas mark 7/425ºF. She does not say how long that preheat takes. Then, “Cook in the oven for about 5 minutes, by which time the cheese should be bubbling and melted.” She adds, be careful not to burn your mouth. That is her serving line. It is not a holding time.

Under make ahead and store, the page says “It is not advisable to make ahead or store.” There is no minute count for how long the melted cheese stays stretched, because she is telling you not to hold the dish.

For this plan

Our reading: tonight fits this page if a topped packet naan is the thing you wanted, the oven is free, and you eat it when it comes out. The 5 minutes start after the oven is already hot. If the cheese has to be sealed inside a dough you mixed today, this is the wrong page. That choice is still open.

The page shows no web publication date. It says the recipe is featured in Nigella Express (2007). We did not read the book. Reader comments on the page are not used. Some of them describe a grill and a longer bake. Those are not her method.

The short version

For people eating tonight, the three stuffed doughs all ask for more than an hour on their own cards. Sanjana Modha’s total is 1 hour 20 minutes. Jennifer Pallian’s total is 1 hour 32 minutes, and the 2-minute cook line does not obviously cover eight naans. Nagi Maehashi’s card lists 20 minutes, 10 minutes, and 2 hours of rising, which add to 2 hours 30 minutes. She never prints that sum. Nigella Lawson’s page is the one that fits a short clock, and it is cheese on a packet naan, about 5 minutes once the oven is hot, for one person. The sheet is in that order so the stuffed clocks sit together. The order is not a ranking.

None of the four pages times how long a cheese pull survives on the table. Sanjana says serve immediately, or keep the naan in an insulated container while you finish the batch, and she does not time the container. Nagi’s finishing line says serve hot, and the cheese section adds no hold. Jennifer covers cooked naan with a towel to keep it warm, and she does not time the towel. Nigella says it is not advisable to make the dish ahead or store it. If the breads have to be ready well before anyone eats, that wait is the gap.

The pans do not transfer. Sanjana’s upside-down method will not work on non-stick, and her both-sides fry says non-stick is fine. Nagi says do not use a non-stick pan. Jennifer’s FAQ says a non-stick skillet or griddle is fine. Follow one cook’s dough and one cook’s pan.

Where the four pages disagree

The dough is the first split. Sanjana’s is yeast-free, with self-raising flour and yogurt, and no egg on the list. She still wants a covered rest of at least 30 minutes, inside a card whose prep line is 1 hour. Jennifer’s is yeast and yogurt, no egg on the list, with 1 hour 15 minutes of resting on the card and about 4 minutes in a mixer, or about 8 to 10 minutes by hand in the FAQ. Nagi’s is yeast, egg, and milk. She writes that no kneading is required, and the card still says 2 hours of rising. Nigella does not make a dough.

Chilling the dough is a second clock, not a shortcut around tonight. Nagi has refrigerated the risen dough 24 hours, then wants it out at least a couple of hours so the second proof still happens. Sanjana says two days in the refrigerator, and best within 48 hours, or the baking powder weakens and the naan is less puffy. Jennifer refrigerates risen balls up to 24 hours, or freezes them up to 3 months, and both paths come back to room temperature before rolling. Those are their clocks for uncooked dough. They are not a safety rule, and they do not erase the cooking once you take the dough out.

The heat is the third split. Sanjana prints a frying pan, an oven at 220°C/430°F for 4 to 5 minutes, and the grill, with a minute or two on both sides in the essay and a few seconds in the notes. Jennifer’s raw dough goes into a covered skillet. Her oven paragraph is reheating. Her gas burner is a few seconds and can burn quickly, and she calls that finish tandoori-style. Nagi’s cheese naan is the cast-iron skillet, hot but not smoking, and she says no fiercely hot tandoor is required. Nigella is only the oven, about 5 minutes. Nobody in this set prints an outdoor grill. Nobody prints a clay-tandoor method, and nobody reports a test that a home pan equals one. We have not run that test.

What fails, in their words, stays with the dough they are writing about. Sanjana: dry or hard dough, a rest you skip, a crack that lets the cheese leak. Jennifer: too much flour, too little rise, too much cheese, a pan that is not hot enough. Nagi: too much egg dries the inside, a non-stick pan at her heat, cold dough that misses the second proof, a single naan that cooks past the 2 to 2 1/2 minutes she calls ideal. Nigella’s limit is the one she states for the finished snack. Do not make it ahead, and do not store it.

Flour, egg, and leftovers, from the FDA

The three stuffed doughs are made with raw flour. Nagi’s dough also includes a raw egg. Nigella starts from a packet naan she tells you to heat. This page does not decide when any of these breads counts as cooked, and it does not give a temperature for the cheese.

The FDA’s Handling Flour Safely page says: “Cooking is the only way to be sure that foods made with flour and raw eggs are safe.” It also says: “Never eat or taste raw flour, dough, or batter.” The same page tells you to refrigerate cookie and pastry dough according to package directions, and to use a refrigerator thermometer to be sure the refrigerator is at a safe 40°F. That refrigerator line is written for cookie and pastry dough. These naan pages are not package directions. The page’s content date reads March 5, 2024. Checked October 28, 2026.

Nagi is the page with egg in the dough. The FDA’s What You Need to Know About Egg Safety page says: “To prevent illness from bacteria: keep eggs refrigerated, cook eggs until yolks are firm, and cook foods containing eggs thoroughly.” The same page says casseroles and other dishes containing eggs should be cooked to 160°F. We are not applying that casserole line to a stuffed naan. She does not print an internal temperature. Content current as of March 5, 2024. Checked October 28, 2026.

Jennifer prints storage times for cooked naan. This page does not repeat them. The FDA’s Safe Food Handling page says: “Refrigerate or freeze meat, poultry, eggs, seafood, and other perishables within 2 hours of cooking or purchasing. Refrigerate within 1 hour if the temperature outside is above 90° F.” The same page has a chart of safe minimum internal temperatures. There is no naan row on it. We are not borrowing a row from that chart, and we are not using the two-hour line to clear or reject a cook’s leftover tin. Content current as of March 5, 2024. Checked October 28, 2026.

“Keep an eye on them at all times to make sure they don’t burn.”

Sanjana Modha, Sanjana Feasts

“Adding too much cheese causes it to leak out during cooking.”

Jennifer Pallian, Foodess

“It is not advisable to make ahead or store.”

Nigella Lawson