Before you make it · No. 21
Apple pie for Thanksgiving
Bake it the day before, or the morning you serve it? Four named recipes make the difference clear before you shop.
If you want the baked pie tomorrow, follow Sally McKenney. After it cools, she says to cover it tightly and keep it at room temperature. Her leftover line is up to 1 day at room temperature, or up to 5 days in the refrigerator. Slice after at least 3 hours. Susan Reid says it is better to bake the pie in advance, cool it completely, then warm each slice as needed after it is cut. She does not number the days. Leftovers on her page keep, lightly covered, at room temperature for several days.
If you want to bake the morning you serve it, follow the King Arthur Test Kitchen. The filling and the crust are made ahead. The filling cools completely before it goes into the crust. You assemble and bake that morning, then cool the pie for several hours before you slice. Deb Perelman does not give a bake-the-day-before line. Her apples sit 1 to 4 hours, the pie bakes, and you wait at least 1 hour before you cut. The filling, she writes, will not fully thicken until the pie has fully cooled, ideally in the fridge for a couple of hours.
The dough is its own clock. McKenney refrigerates it at least 2 hours before using, and she stores it up to 5 days in the refrigerator or up to 3 months in the freezer. The Test Kitchen chills it at least 30 minutes and up to 2 days, or freezes it up to 2 months. Reid’s page says 30 minutes before rolling. Perelman says an hour or two if the dough needs chilling before you roll it, and she allows store-bought dough. None of these four pages tells you to fill the crust tonight and bake it tomorrow.
The filling does not enter the crust the same way. McKenney’s pre-cook is optional, about 5 minutes, then a slight cool, and she says it is ok if the filling is still warm. The Test Kitchen pre-cooks the apples and transfers the cooled filling. Reid and Perelman do not pre-cook. Follow one cook’s page all the way through. Reid’s classic pie and the Test Kitchen’s make-ahead-filling pie are different recipes from the same kitchen. The dough, the filling, and the wait before you slice stay with the page you cook.
At a glance
How each recipe fits this plan
- No image yet
Sally McKenney
Make it 1 day ahead. After it cools, cover it tightly and keep it at room temperature. The optional pre-cook can go into the crust still warm. Slice after at least 3 hours.
Fits your plan Warm filling is allowed Recipe by Sally McKenney, Sally’s Baking Addiction - No image yet
Susan Reid
Refrigerate the dough 30 minutes. The filling is raw apples. Bake in advance, cool completely, then warm slices. She does not number the days. Leftovers keep at room temperature for several days.
Plan around this No day count Recipe by Susan Reid, King Arthur Baking - No image yet
King Arthur Test Kitchen
Cool the pre-cooked filling completely before it goes into the crust. The filling keeps up to 4 days in the refrigerator. The dough keeps up to 2 days. Assemble and bake the morning you serve it, then cool several hours.
Plan around this Bake the morning of Recipe by King Arthur Test Kitchen - No image yet
Deb Perelman
Let raw apple slices sit 1 to 4 hours at room temperature, then bake. Cool at least 1 hour before cutting. She does not print a bake-the-day-before line. Leftovers keep 2 to 3 days at room temperature.
Plan around this No bake-ahead line Recipe by Deb Perelman, Smitten Kitchen
Sally McKenney
Fits your planWarm filling is allowedFrom My Favorite Apple Pie Recipe by Sally McKenney, Sally’s Baking Addiction. Updated September 2, 2026 (originally published in 2018).
- Dough
- At least 2 hours; up to 5 days
- Filling into crust
- Optional pre-cook; warm is ok
- Before slicing
- At least 3 hours
- Baked pie
- 1 day ahead, room temperature
Susan Reid
Plan around thisNo day countFrom Apple Pie by Susan Reid, King Arthur Baking. Updated October 29, 2026.
- Dough
- 30 minutes
- Filling into crust
- Raw
- Before slicing
- Cool completely
- Baked pie
- In advance; no day count
King Arthur Test Kitchen
Plan around thisBake the morning ofFrom Apple Pie with Make-Ahead Filling by King Arthur Test Kitchen. Updated August 19, 2025.
- Dough
- 30 minutes to 2 days
- Filling into crust
- Cool completely
- Before slicing
- Several hours
- Bake
- The morning you serve
Deb Perelman
Plan around thisNo bake-ahead lineFrom Even More Perfect Apple Pie by Deb Perelman, Smitten Kitchen. Published October 18, 2018; updated November 12, 2024.
- Apples before crust
- 1 to 4 hours, room temperature
- Dough chill
- An hour or two, if needed
- Before slicing
- At least 1 hour
- Leftovers
- 2 to 3 days, room temperature
The four recipes
Reid’s classic pie and the Test Kitchen’s make-ahead-filling pie share a publisher. They are different recipes. The times below stay on the page that printed them.
| Cook | Dough | Filling into the crust | When it bakes | Before you slice | After it is baked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| McKenney, Sally’s Baking Addiction | At least 2 hours. Refrigerator up to 5 days, or freezer up to 3 months. | Optional 5-minute pre-cook, then slightly cool. Still warm is ok. | 1 day ahead. After it cools, cover tightly and keep at room temperature. | At least 3 hours. The card total is 7 hours and includes cooling. | Room temperature up to 1 day, or refrigerator up to 5 days. A baked pie also freezes up to 3 months. |
| Reid, King Arthur Baking | 30 minutes before rolling. The assembled pie gets 10 minutes in the refrigerator while the oven heats. | Raw apples, tossed and spooned in. No pre-cook. | In advance, then cool completely. She does not number the days. | Completely. No hour count. Cut too soon, the filling runs. | Lightly covered, room temperature, for several days. Freeze for longer storage. No month count. |
| Test Kitchen, King Arthur Baking | At least 30 minutes, up to 2 days in the refrigerator, or 2 months in the freezer. | Pre-cooked. Cool completely before it goes in. Up to 4 days, airtight, in the refrigerator. | The morning you serve it. | Completely. The method says this takes several hours. | Lightly covered, room temperature, for several days. Freeze for longer storage. No month count. |
| Perelman, Smitten Kitchen | An hour or two if it needs chilling before rolling. Store-bought dough is allowed. No multi-day dough line on this page. | Raw slices sit 1 to 4 hours at room temperature. The juices go in with them. | No bake-ahead line. The method is the day you bake. | At least 1 hour at room temperature. It will not fully thicken until fully cooled, ideally a couple of hours in the fridge. | Room temperature for 2 to 3 days, or the refrigerator for 1 week. |
A few details that change the slice:
- McKenney’s card lists 3 hours prep, including the crust, a cook time of 1 hour 5 minutes, and a total of 7 hours, which includes cooling. The method still says at least 3 hours before slicing, and that the filling will be too juicy if the pie is warm. Reid’s card lists 45 minutes hands-on, a bake of 55 minutes to 1 hour 5 minutes, and a total of 2 hours. Her cool-completely line has no minute count. The Test Kitchen’s card lists 40 minutes hands-on, a bake of 55 minutes to 1 hour 5 minutes, and a total of 2 hours 20 minutes. The method then says cooling completely will take several hours. Perelman prints no card total. She bakes 75 minutes at 400°F, then waits at least 1 hour.
- The Test Kitchen headnote says to make the filling and the crust several days in advance, then bake the morning you want the pie. The method is tighter. Filling, up to 4 days, airtight, refrigerated. Dough, at least 30 minutes and up to 2 days in the refrigerator, or up to 2 months in the freezer, thawed overnight in the refrigerator. Use the method’s numbers.
- McKenney’s make-ahead note and her leftover line both name 1 day at room temperature. The leftover line also names the refrigerator, up to 5 days. The make-ahead note also freezes a baked pie for up to 3 months: thaw overnight in the refrigerator, then let it come to room temperature. Her prepared filling can be frozen up to 3 months and thawed overnight in the refrigerator before using. She does not print a refrigerator hold for unbaked filling.
- A short chill of the assembled pie is a same-session step. McKenney’s optional 20 to 30 minutes sets the lattice before baking. Reid’s 10 minutes firms the crust while the oven finishes heating. Neither line is an overnight, unbaked pie.
- A bubbling filling is the doneness cue they share. McKenney also says the filling is done at around 200°F (93°C). Perelman also says 195°F, or a tester that does not hit an overtly crunchy piece. Reid wants the filling bubbling vigorously. The Test Kitchen wants it bubbling through the vents, with a golden crust. Those readings stay on the page that printed them.
- McKenney’s card says the pie serves 8 to 10. Reid and the Test Kitchen each say one 9-inch pie. Perelman does not print a serving count.
After it is baked, from the official pages
The room-temperature lines above are what each cook printed about a baked fruit pie. This page does not add a hold of its own.
The USDA’s Leftovers and Food Safety page says leftovers must be refrigerated within 2 hours of cooking, and within 1 hour if the temperature is over 90°F. It says to throw away perishable food left at room temperature longer than that. The same page says leftovers can be kept in the refrigerator for 3 to 4 days or frozen for 3 to 4 months. It does not name apple pie or fruit pie. Last updated July 31, 2020. Checked November 10, 2026.
Food Safety During Power Outage, on FoodSafety.gov, is a chart for refrigerated food exposed to 40°F (4°C) or above for more than 2 hours after a power outage. In that chart, fruit pies are marked Keep. Pies whose filling contains eggs or milk, the examples being custard, cheese-filled, or chiffon, and quiche, are marked Discard. Date last reviewed August 8, 2024. Checked November 10, 2026. That chart is for a power outage.
Open both links before you rely on them. The cooks’ room-temperature lines and these two official pages do not use the same clock.
“It’s ok if it is still warm from the precooking step.”
Sally McKenney, Sally’s Baking Addiction
“Cutting any fruit pie that’s still warm is a messy business.”
Susan Reid, King Arthur Baking
“Apple pie filling can be made up to 4 days ahead. Store airtight in the refrigerator.”
King Arthur Test Kitchen
“Cool pie for at least one hour at room temperature before cutting into it.”
Deb Perelman, Smitten Kitchen